Good Morning!

Howdy, partner.

Today we’re going to talk about the dangers of overthinking and rumination, with Notes from Underground by Fyodor Dostoyevsky as our central text. Burning that off, we’re going to do the Overthinking Check. Wrapping up, we’ll pull a short quote from Notes from Underground.

Have a seat, Thought Breakfast is served!

We tend to think that self-awareness is always a strength. The more we understand ourselves, the better we live, right? Naturally, a heightened sense of self-awareness would push someone to confront their flaws and become the best version of themselves. Well, Dostoyevsky complicates that idea. In Notes from Underground, the narrator isn’t just aware; he’s hyper-aware. He believes he sees everything clearly: his thoughts, motives, contradictions, and insecurities. Instead of freeing him, that awareness traps him. It leads to utter paralysis.

The Underground Man explains away everything. He is constantly constructing arguments for why he acts, doesn’t act, and why others are always wrong. He is an intelligent man with a respectable career, but that intelligence becomes a mere shield that he hides behind when facing reality. Instead of admitting weakness, he hyper-analyzes it. Instead of acting, he tries to explain why action is impossible. Dostoyevsky reveals something very uncomfortable here: Intelligence can become a way to avoid reality. Being hyper-aware doesn’t just mean we think deeply, it can mean we hide behind thought.

Overthinking even feels productive. It feels like reflection, meditation, depth, or insight. Sometimes it’s just repetition: replaying conversations, rewriting decisions, anticipating outcomes endlessly. The Underground Man lives almost entirely in his head. The more he thinks, the less he actually lives. Not all thinking leads forward. Sometimes thinking does just keep us stuck.

Mental health isn’t just about understanding yourself. It’s about moving, even without full clarity. We want to wait for certainty, perfect explanations, and the right feelings, but life doesn’t wait for resolution. Action has to come first. You can understand yourself endlessly and still avoid living. The challenge is not a matter of awareness, but more about stepping out of your own head.

Ask yourself:

Try to find one place where you can move forward without overthinking it.

“To be too conscious is an illness — a real, thorough illness.”
— Fyodor Dostoyevsky, Notes from Underground

Dostoyevsky blatantly calls excessive consciousness an illness. Awareness, without action, does turn into total paralysis. Overthinking can feel like depth, but often function as avoidance. The goal isn’t to have less awareness, not at all. The goal is to balance awareness with action. Are you thinking to understand? Or thinking to avoid?

Munch on that for today. Have a great day, and come back tomorrow for another steaming hot plate of Thought Breakfast!

Retirement looks different for everyone. What it costs, where the income comes from, how long it needs to last. Those answers are specific to you.

The Definitive Guide to Retirement Income helps investors with $1,000,000 or more work through the questions that matter and build a plan around the answers.

Download your free guide to start turning a savings number into an actual retirement income strategy.

Remember to stay mindful, smell the flowers, and take it easy.

Chef Ricky - Thought Breakfast